The recall device began in the United States in the Los Angeles municipality in 1903. Michigan and Oregon, in 1908, were the first states to adopt recall procedures for state officials; Minnesota was the most recent (1996) example. The right to recall has been largely successful in terms of local bodies rather than for state officials. In the US, only two governors have been successfully recalled In 1921 — North Dakota’s Lynn J Frazier was recalled over a dispute about state-owned industries, and in 2003, California Governor Gray Davis was recalled over mismanagement of the state budget.
As far as Indian constitution is concerned, it is very much important for our society to have the right to recall as a fundamental right. We must have this right in order to stop the corruption that is taking place in the Indian government. The Common Wealth Games for instance was a huge flop due to internal corruption taking place among the core-committee members. Therefore it is our duty and right as citizens of India to choose the right candidate in the constitution to avoid further uncertainties.
Detailed Information About Right To Recall in English .:
It means exact procedure by which citizens replace PM, Supreme Court judges, CM, MPs, MLAs, Reserve Bank Governor or any official from PM to Collector to Sarpanch if the need be. What is the importance of RTR?
Well, let me ask you one question first. The question is very important. Say you own a factory with 100 employees such as managers, laborers etc. And suddenly Govt makes 2 new rules –
1. you can NOT expel managers till they are 65 years and cant expel any workers for next 5 years
2. every month, money from your account will be deducted and salary will go to your employees.
My question to you is : then after three months, will the level of indiscipline increase or decrease? I will re-ask this question : three months after these new rules come, will level of indiscipline increase or decrease? Pls read further only after answering this question.
IOW, if we the commons of India, can not expel judges, MPs, Ministers, IAS etc they will all become indisciplined, corrupt, nepotic etc. This is what Shri Sanyal, Guru of Bhagat Singh said in 1925. RTR was implemented in Greece in 600 BC and made Greece so powerful that Greece could win up to the river Yamuna. And has been implemented in US since 1800s and is main reason why US has been able to conquer Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Pakistan, Libya and India may be next. But one doesn’t need examples of Greece and US to get the idea behind of right to recall --- it is plain vanilla common sense. Most problems of us commons in India are not different from the factory owner who can not fire workers for 5-35 years. And the solutions to our problems is also trivial --- procedures by which we may expel officers, Ministers, judges.
Why IYO corruption in US policemen and judges is less than corruption in India's policemen and judges? Are policemen and judges in US so dumb that they dont know how to squeeze money from citizens? Or are they all saints and dont want any extra money? Surely, not. And if we say education is the reason, then are policemen/judges in India illiterate? All this are non-reasons. The real reason why policemen/judges in US take much less bribes than policemen/judges in India is only because citizens in US have procedures by which they can expel/replace District Police Commissioner and District Judges. Why do judgments in US courts come in 6 months in over 99% cases? Because citizens have Right to Recall District Judges, High Court Chief Judges, District Public Prosecutors etc.
As far as Indian constitution is concerned, it is very much important for our society to have the right to recall as a fundamental right. We must have this right in order to stop the corruption that is taking place in the Indian government. The Common Wealth Games for instance was a huge flop due to internal corruption taking place among the core-committee members. Therefore it is our duty and right as citizens of India to choose the right candidate in the constitution to avoid further uncertainties.
Detailed Information About Right To Recall in English .:
What is this Right to Recall in short?
It means exact procedure by which citizens replace PM, Supreme Court judges, CM, MPs, MLAs, Reserve Bank Governor or any official from PM to Collector to Sarpanch if the need be. What is the importance of RTR?Well, let me ask you one question first. The question is very important. Say you own a factory with 100 employees such as managers, laborers etc. And suddenly Govt makes 2 new rules –
1. you can NOT expel managers till they are 65 years and cant expel any workers for next 5 years
2. every month, money from your account will be deducted and salary will go to your employees.
My question to you is : then after three months, will the level of indiscipline increase or decrease? I will re-ask this question : three months after these new rules come, will level of indiscipline increase or decrease? Pls read further only after answering this question.
IOW, if we the commons of India, can not expel judges, MPs, Ministers, IAS etc they will all become indisciplined, corrupt, nepotic etc. This is what Shri Sanyal, Guru of Bhagat Singh said in 1925. RTR was implemented in Greece in 600 BC and made Greece so powerful that Greece could win up to the river Yamuna. And has been implemented in US since 1800s and is main reason why US has been able to conquer Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Pakistan, Libya and India may be next. But one doesn’t need examples of Greece and US to get the idea behind of right to recall --- it is plain vanilla common sense. Most problems of us commons in India are not different from the factory owner who can not fire workers for 5-35 years. And the solutions to our problems is also trivial --- procedures by which we may expel officers, Ministers, judges.
Why IYO corruption in US policemen and judges is less than corruption in India's policemen and judges? Are policemen and judges in US so dumb that they dont know how to squeeze money from citizens? Or are they all saints and dont want any extra money? Surely, not. And if we say education is the reason, then are policemen/judges in India illiterate? All this are non-reasons. The real reason why policemen/judges in US take much less bribes than policemen/judges in India is only because citizens in US have procedures by which they can expel/replace District Police Commissioner and District Judges. Why do judgments in US courts come in 6 months in over 99% cases? Because citizens have Right to Recall District Judges, High Court Chief Judges, District Public Prosecutors etc.
Post a Comment